Is Vaping at Work Gross Misconduct?

With the rise of e-cigarette use, questions about vaping on business premises and in the workplace have become increasingly important. Although vaping isn’t covered by the same laws as smoking in the UK, its acceptability at work often hinges on company policies and the context of the situation. This guide explores whether vaping at work can be classified as gross misconduct and how employers and employees can navigate this nuanced issue.

Legal Framework in the UK: Smoking vs. Vaping

Under the Health Act 2006, smoking is prohibited in enclosed public places and workplaces in the UK. However, this legislation does not extend to vaping, as e-cigarettes don’t involve burning tobacco or producing smoke. This distinction means vaping is not automatically banned in workplaces. Instead, the decision is left to employers, who have the discretion to establish their own policies regarding e-cigarette use during work hours.

Health Risks and Concerns

According to Public Health England, vaping is at least 95% less harmful than smoking cigarettes, but it's important to remember that vaping at work may still pose potential health risks to employees and others in the workplace. The long-term health effects of vaping are not yet fully understood, but several concerns have been identified:

• Exposure to secondhand vapour: Unlike smoking, vaping doesn’t produce smoke, but it does release vapour that may contain harmful chemicals and particles. This secondhand vapour can affect the health of non-vaping employees, potentially exacerbating existing respiratory issues.
• Nicotine: E-cigarettes often contain nicotine, which is highly addictive. Employees who vape may be at risk of developing or maintaining a nicotine addiction, which can have various health implications.
• Device malfunctions: There have been instances of vaping devices malfunctioning, leading to explosions and fires. This poses a significant safety risk in the workplace, especially in environments with flammable materials.

Employers should carefully consider these potential health risks when deciding whether to permit vaping at work. Implementing clear policies and designated vaping areas can help minimise any potential harm to employees and others in the workplace.

Vaping at Work Policies: The Importance of Clarity

Workplace policies on vaping vary widely, reflecting differing organisational cultures and operational needs. Clear policies are essential for avoiding misunderstandings and ensuring consistent enforcement. The decision of whether or not to allow vaping is left to employers, who have the discretion to establish their own rules regarding e-cigarette use during work hours.

Some employers permit vaping in designated areas, such as outdoor spaces, while others implement blanket bans on e-cigarette use within their premises. Ambiguities in these policies can lead to inconsistent application and potential disputes.

A notable case illustrating the importance of policy clarity is Insley v. Accent Catering, where an employee faced a disciplinary hearing for vaping on school premises. The tribunal noted that the school’s smoking policy didn’t explicitly prohibit e-cigarettes, underscoring the need for explicit guidelines.

Employee Rights and Responsibilities

Employees have the right to a safe and healthy work environment, and employers are responsible for providing it. When it comes to vaping at work, employees should be aware of their rights and responsibilities to ensure a harmonious and safe workplace:

• Right to know company policies: Employees have the right to be informed about their company’s policies on vaping at work. Clear communication from HR professionals is essential to ensure everyone understands the rules.
• Right to a safe environment: Employees are entitled to a work environment free from secondhand vapour. This includes having access to designated vaping areas if permitted.
• Responsibility to follow policies: Employees must adhere to their company’s policies on vaping at work. This includes using designated areas and respecting any restrictions in place.
• Responsibility to respect colleagues: Employees should be mindful of their colleagues, especially those who may be sensitive to secondhand vapour. Respecting shared spaces and exercising discretion can help maintain a professional and considerate workplace.

HR professionals play a crucial role in ensuring that employees are aware of their rights and responsibilities.

Can Vaping at Work Be Gross Misconduct?

Whether vaping at work constitutes gross misconduct depends on the circumstances and company policies. Generally, gross misconduct involves serious breaches of workplace rules or behaviours that undermine trust or safety. Vaping in violation of clear policies, especially in areas where health and safety are at risk, can escalate from minor misconduct to gross misconduct if the behaviour is repeated or particularly egregious.

For example, vaping in areas with flammable materials or in enclosed spaces where it might disturb colleagues could be deemed severe enough to warrant disciplinary action. However, in workplaces with ambiguous policies, such actions might be harder to classify as gross misconduct.

Potential Consequences of Vaping at Work

Violating workplace policies on electronic cigarettes can lead to a range of outcomes depending on the severity of the incident and the organisation’s stance. Consequences might include verbal warnings, formal reprimands, or even dismissal in cases of gross misconduct. Consistent enforcement of policies is crucial for fairness and avoiding potential legal challenges.

Best Practices for Employers and Employees

For employers: Establishing clear and explicit vaping policies is the first step to managing e-cigarette use in the workplace. These policies should outline acceptable behaviours, designated vaping areas (if any), and the consequences of policy violations. Employers should also ensure consistent enforcement to maintain fairness and compliance across the organisation. Employers may also want to consider the needs and perspectives of former smokers when developing vaping policies.

For employees: Employees should familiarise themselves with their organisation’s vaping policies to avoid unintentional breaches. Even if no explicit policy exists, exercising discretion is key to maintaining professionalism. Choosing designated outdoor areas and being mindful of colleagues can help create a harmonious work environment.

Vaping in Shared Workspaces: A Delicate Balance

Vaping in shared spaces such as toilets, open-plan offices, or break rooms can raise issues of etiquette and professionalism, impacting where an employee works. Although some workplaces might permit vaping in private areas, doing so without consideration for colleagues can lead to complaints or disciplinary action. Respecting shared spaces and seeking clarity on designated vaping areas can help mitigate potential conflicts.

Clear Policies and Open Communication Are Key

Vaping at work is not inherently classified as gross misconduct, but the use of vapes can be deemed as such depending on the specific circumstances and the clarity of workplace policies. For employers, developing and enforcing clear guidelines is essential to maintaining a fair and respectful environment. For employees, understanding and adhering to these policies — and exercising discretion where rules are unclear — can help avoid misunderstandings and disciplinary measures.

By fostering open communication and clear expectations, both employers and employees can navigate the evolving landscape of vaping in the workplace with confidence and professionalism.

Want to learn more about smoke-free alternatives that fit your needs?